Doorly's XO Review

Doorly’s XO represents Foursquare Distillery’s approach to accessible premium rum, delivering a blend of pot and column still distillates finished in Oloroso sherry casks. This Barbadian expression offers quality construction at an accessible price point, typically retailing around $15-30.

Technical Assessment

The rum combines molasses-based pot and column still distillate, with initial maturation in ex-bourbon casks for 5 years followed by 1-3 years in Oloroso sherry casks. While carrying “XO” designation, no formal age statement appears on the bottle, as Barbados maintains no legal definition for this marking. The blend utilizes aged rum stocks ranging from six to ten years, with batch variation possible to maintain consistent taste profile.

The 40% bottling strength provides accessibility while maintaining the structural integrity necessary for both neat consumption and cocktail applications. This represents classic Bajan style rum construction without additives beyond the sherry cask influence.

Nose Evaluation

The aromatic presentation demonstrates the benefits of dual maturation methodology. Vanilla characteristics establish the foundation, supported by dried fruit complexity that reflects both bourbon barrel aging and sherry cask finishing. The nutty elements add textural depth beyond simple sweetness, creating layered aromatics that reward examination. The integration demonstrates competent blending across the stated maturation periods.

Palate Analysis

The palate execution maintains consistency with aromatic promises while introducing additional complexity. Rich vanilla provides the structural backbone, with orange and spice elements creating balanced progression. Oak influence presents with spicy characteristics and sweet caramel, while fruit notes remain present but controlled. The mouthfeel demonstrates appropriate weight for the proof without excessive heat interference.

Finish Assessment

The conclusion presents measured persistence with minimal alcohol heat and controlled spice presence, though some reviewers note the finish as disappointingly soft and short-lived. The warm, nutty characteristics documented in testing provide satisfying conclusion while maintaining the integrated profile established throughout the tasting experience.

Performance Context

Doorly’s XO functions effectively across multiple applications, serving both as contemplative sipper and versatile cocktail base, particularly in classics like Corn ’n’ Oil. The accessible pricing makes it suitable for cocktail experimentation while offering sufficient complexity for neat consumption. The rum performs well in rocks glass service with ice and functions effectively as premium mixer.

Final Assessment

Doorly’s XO executes its role as solid Bajan rum with substantial character, maintaining rum identity despite sherry influence. The expression successfully delivers balanced, double-matured Barbadian character within its budget-friendly positioning. The technical execution reflects Foursquare’s production competence while offering entry-level access to sherry-finished rum category. Within its price segment, it represents reliable value for those seeking authentic Caribbean rum character with extended maturation influence.